Wisconsin Supreme Court’s new majority allows the use of ballot drop boxes in swing state.

The Wisconsin Supreme Court’s new liberal majority has made a significant ruling that could impact the upcoming elections in the swing state. The decision involved the use of ballot drop boxes, which were banned under a previous ruling by the conservative majority. However, the new ruling has reversed this ban, allowing election officials to reinstate the use of drop boxes before the November elections. 

Previously, in July 2022, the state Supreme Court, which was under a conservative majority, determined that absentee ballot drop boxes were not authorized under state statute. The ruling stated that the Wisconsin Elections Commission (WEC) guidance encouraging the use of drop boxes was unlawful. This decision was based on a state statute that required absentee ballots to be returned either by mail or in person to the municipal clerk, ruling out the use of offsite and unattended drop boxes. 

However, in a recent 4-3 ruling, the court’s liberal majority reversed this decision. Justice Anna Walsh Bradley, writing for the majority, argued that the state statute does not specify the location to which a ballot must be returned and allows for discretion by municipal clerks in designating drop box locations. The dissenting conservative justices accused the majority of engaging in politically motivated activism, highlighting the contentious nature of the decision. 

The shift in the court’s composition came after Democratic-backed candidate Janet Protaswiecz won a seat, giving liberals a 4-3 majority. This change in power prompted Priorities USA, a progressive group, to request a review of the ban on drop boxes. Democratic Gov. Tony Evers and Republican lawmakers also weighed in on the issue, reflecting the partisan divide on this matter. 

Drop boxes have been a source of controversy, with Republicans alleging that they facilitate cheating and Democrats promoting them as a way to enhance voter convenience and accessibility. The recent ruling has reignited debates over election security and integrity, with both parties expressing concerns and objections. 

Despite the differing opinions, election officials like Scott McDonell, the Dane County Clerk, have emphasized the benefits of drop boxes in improving the electoral process. McDonell contends that drop boxes offer a convenient alternative for voters, especially in rural areas, and help reduce the risk of ballots arriving late. 

As the state gears up for the 2024 elections, the decision on drop boxes is expected to have a significant impact on voter turnout and participation. The debate over election security, access, and integrity is likely to continue as Wisconsin remains a crucial swing state in national politics. 

Ultimately, the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s ruling on drop boxes reflects the broader challenges and controversies surrounding elections in the current political climate. The decision has implications that extend beyond the state’s borders, underscoring the importance of electoral policies and practices in shaping the democratic process. 

As the nation prepares for the upcoming elections, the debate over drop boxes serves as a reminder of the ongoing struggle to balance security and accessibility in the electoral system. The Wisconsin Supreme Court’s decision adds another layer of complexity to this complex issue, highlighting the need for ongoing dialogue and engagement on matters of democracy and governance.